Originally Posted by
dawg80
In some places, in a given time in history, US military occupation made sense/makes sense. Such as our involvement in Japan and Germany post WWII and in South Korea. But, any history student can tell you Afghanistan is not the place for such occupation.
I can dig out the article for more details, but I read an accounting of the British attempt to "subdue" Afghanistan back in the 1870's. About 20,000 crack British troops invaded Afghanistan, captured Kabul fairly easily, and then entered into an alliance with "friendly" Afghan tribes to stand against an army of unfriendly tribes. About 60,000 Afghan warriors joined the Brits as they marched north to engage the enemy, an army numbering over 100,000.
The night before the battle, emissaries of the enemy tribes bribed and coerced the friendlies to switch sides. The next day the British army of a mere 20,000 faced one of 160,000 which had them flanked and partially surrounded. A Brit rear guard of 8,000 men made a bold and heroic stand in what is one of the most incredible such last stands in military history.
"Only the dog survived...and even he was seriously wounded." One of the Brit regiments, numbering 800 soldiers, had a dog as a mascot. After a day of brutal combat against over-whelming odds, and after inflicting an estimated 35,000 casualties on the attacking Afghans, the Brit rear guard gave way. Every officer and man of that regiment was killed in action. A 100% casualty rate. The dog was slashed by a Afghan soldier with a sword and left to die. Only he survived and was later found walking slowly on the road to Kabul by British cavalry sent to assist the remnants of the retreating rear guard. Fewer than 1,500 of the 8,000 survived, and every one of them had been wounded. The dog became a national hero once back in England, a symbol of that gallant stand by that regiment vs. impossible odds.
The British general in command of the Afghan expedition reported to his superiors that he was pulling all his men out of that "God-forsaken country" retiring back to their bases in India. And that no nation, no matter how powerful it may be, will ever be able to subdue Afghanistan. Why won't the world listen to these sage words?