2004 NFL draft revisited

So let's take your pick. Knowing what you know now about each of these QB's, who would have of taken??

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by DocMarvin362

So let's take your pick. Knowing what you know now about each of these QB's, who would have of taken??

---

Big Ben for sure!!

Based on performance to date, it's obviously Ben R., but I'm not sure that isn't heavily weighted to coaching. I still think Eli has the potential to be a better QB that he is. Roth is in a perfect situation for him, Eli is in a rather poor fit situation. Things may change if there's a coaching change.

But if I had to draft one for a fantasy team next year, it'd be Roth for sure.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TechDawgMc

Based on performance to date, it's obviously Ben R., but I'm not sure that isn't heavily weighted to coaching. I still think Eli has the potential to be a better QB that he is. Roth is in a perfect situation for him, Eli is in a rather poor fit situation. Things may change if there's a coaching change.

But if I had to draft one for a fantasy team next year, it'd be Roth for sure.

---

I think Eli would do well to get out of NYC. He'll always be under the microscope because he's Peyton's brother, but being in New York magnifies the scrutiny exponentially. I think if Eli were in Cleveland or Green Bay, he'd be doing MUCH better. Carolina would be a GREAT fit IMO.