Search:

Cook will be a HUGE star! I was glad he won, but a little surprised. Some goofy pats to the show last night, but some good ones too. ZZ Top singing with David Cook in lead was cool. Plus, Nash...

The boxing analogy was lame, I agree.

As for the performances, David A. brought it and David C. didn't. David C. is still the most talented and will be the biggest star. I tink David A. wins...

David Cook does best when it is a song that is not meant for him to sing (ala Dolly, Mariah, or some oldie). He revamps the song and makes it shine. There are songs from the 60's thru the 80's that...

Actually, I liked Criminal Minds until they got a little too ridiculous. When you spot things that are entirely inaccuarate, it makes you question the whole show. All in all, though, it is...

Castro is out tonight
Syesha earned me some respect with her second song
David A. can only sing one type song, but he CAN sing. He is more your Enriche Iglesis (sp?) type singer. Don't...

OK, so here is my real assessment. I agree with some of you and don't with others.

Brooke - needed to go, but she has some potential. I don't think she was fake at all. I think she was very...

Cook is an entertainer. You don't have to have the best voice in the competition to be the biggest star. He is total star potential. Actually, little David A. has a very pure and nice voice, but...

Well, Brooke is gone........... She had a much more sad reaction than I expected. Anyway, dreadlocks is still in - which REALLY surprised me. He should be next off and should have been off before...

Brooke is a star. She is a Carlie Simon/Jewel/Sheryl Crow type star. David Cook will win it all. He is modern, original, and can entertain. David A. will end up on Broadway, as well Syesha(sp?). ...

The little boy might do well too. Brooke could change it up some and excel next week. And, you KNOW, that Cook will change it up. Syesha may be the one in trouble.

Well, the wrong person went out last night. I don't see how dreadlocks is still in the competition. His number is coming up next, I am sure. Smithson being booted may be the best thing to happen...

Yes, I am the same way. I loathe reality shows, but this one hooked me in.

I was surprised about Brooke, as well. However, the right one got eliminated. Brooke can make up for it this next...

I agree. Castro did a good job last night, as well. Brooke got hammered by Simon, but I thought she did great - until towards the end of the song.

My top 2 are still Brooke and David. I think...

David Cook nailed it again last night. The guy is a pro!

I was very surprised that Johns got kicked off. Bigdog is right about him nailing that song on the second time and Ryan's cold hearted slam.

I think the country girl is the next one off. Good...

He fits the image of current male singers. Cut from that same mold. He can make it just off of image, a decent voice, and a good songwriter.

I really believe that 5 or 6 of these will make it big. Johns is one of them.

The Danny guy. The male stripper was, actually, ok.

Yeah, I like the hippie ok, as well, but I think either he or that Cook girl will go down next (no pun intended).

I thought that at first, but not so sure about it. I think more just a free spirit hippy type guy. Now, that one guy that made it to the top 11 was WAY over the top. That wasn't sugar in his...

Sure looks more like a U of Texas guy than an A&M guy.

Yeah, David Cook is the one. He is the most talented on there and already sounds like a pro. I see him in a band, though.

David Archuleta is definitely going to be the teen's favorite, but I...

God, this is embarrassing, but I DID get hooked this year. There are two guys that I think are really good, but I don't know which is which. David Archuleta is the little kid, right? He is very...