Based soley on speculation of course. Terry would have still started as an upper classman at Tech and had same chance to play in NFL. If there were no speculation there would be no news in most cases.
The most I got out of that is Phil saying "this is the first time I have been back".
Phil Robertson's years at Tech:
1964-Did not play
1965-Played very little behind Billy Laird
1966-Shared playing time with Bradshaw. Team went 1-9 and averaged 8.3 points/game. Robertson was 90/205 for 1,011 yds, 4 TDs, 18 int.
1967-Shared playing time with Bradshaw. Team went 3-7 and averaged 15.6 points/game. No stats for Robinson in the media guide because Bradshaw was the leading passer with 981 yds.
1968- Quit the team and took up duck hunting full time.
Yeppers. I know of TWO former BOP members who live in West Monroe and they have been to exactly ONE game since their graduation in the mid-90's. And that was for a HC game with some special BOP gathering.
But...a former player, who lives so close. I would expect him to have attended a game or two...at least...every year. Although, it appears he wasn't all that interested in football even when he was playing it...
He was married with 1 kid. He took up commercial fishing.
I know several former players living close who never come back. Some live in Lincoln Parish and go to lsu crap instead. Robertson spends his free time in church or church related activities.
Yep....when you and I were both at Tech, until Bradshaw took over at QB, football sucked. Bradshaw was easily the better QB. Sorry, but that is just the reality of it all. Robertson had to grow up to become the man he is today. He was not either "father of the year" or "husband of the year" during his '20's and later. Bradshaw played all of 1968 and even if Robertson had not quit, he would have been second team.
I was also there for his three playing years. He had his one good game against Lamar in 1967 when they were a small college powerhouse. We also beat Arkansas State that year and they were hot shots, too, but that was by the field goal kicker. I believe the score in that game was 6-3. My personal feeling at the time was that he saw the handwriting on the wall and didn't want to bother if he wasn't going to play.
Looks like he did graduate in 1969 according to my Alumni Directory. He appears to not be one of the rah rah guys. If he supported LSU he might be faulted. Otherwise he's just up there with all the other "meh" graduates.
I was there when they both played. Phil wasn't going to play even if Terry had been average. Once Terry got some training, he eclipsed Phil. Phil just wasn't good.
I lived next to Phil's brother, Tommy, in Vetville for a year, and Phil would come in with ice chests full of bass, and none of them were small. So he wasn't just a duck hunter, he was an excellent fisherman as well.
Just my opinion, but I think Phil had the physical tools to be a great qb, but he had too many outside interests to put in the work required to become a great college qb. Terry on the other hand loved the game.
I remember one time, before they built the new stadium, I was playing a pickup football game in the old stadium, when Bradshaw showed up, and started playing with us. That's how much he loved the game.
FYI, he threw me one pass while I was all alone in the end zone, and it went between my hands and my head (what an athlete). Needless to say he didn't throw another one my way.