Hey Spinoza, long time no chat.
I thought I might interject here and provide you another such venue, if you wished to join elsewhere:
http://www.christiandiscussionforums.org/v/index.php
This is a place where I post often (although will post less since school is starting soon) and is a place where you will find people from all manner of background. While it is primarily a Christian discussion board (in the sense that most of the topics are related to Christianity), there are also sections where you can post about other religions and even general stuff (like science).
Another place I was invited to post at (by a friend) but have yet to post on is:
www.christianforums.com
Again, this place is primarily Christian, but it's segmented into "Christian only" and "all members welcome" sections, such that you can find a lot of different types of topics. In fact, in their "all members welcome" section, they have a "discussion and debate" section which has these topics:
Anyway, I thought you might be interested in searching on these boards to find something more to your liking. You will encounter more theology/philosophy on those boards than on this one, not that that's bad or anything. It's just this one doesn't specialize in theology/philosophy but in sports.
Daniel