So let's take your pick. Knowing what you know now about each of these QB's, who would have of taken??
Eli Manning
Ben Rothlisberger
Phillip Rivers
So let's take your pick. Knowing what you know now about each of these QB's, who would have of taken??
Based on performance to date, it's obviously Ben R., but I'm not sure that isn't heavily weighted to coaching. I still think Eli has the potential to be a better QB that he is. Roth is in a perfect situation for him, Eli is in a rather poor fit situation. Things may change if there's a coaching change.
But if I had to draft one for a fantasy team next year, it'd be Roth for sure.
I think Eli would do well to get out of NYC. He'll always be under the microscope because he's Peyton's brother, but being in New York magnifies the scrutiny exponentially. I think if Eli were in Cleveland or Green Bay, he'd be doing MUCH better. Carolina would be a GREAT fit IMO.
Time is your friend. Impulse is your enemy. -John Bogle