
Originally Posted by
RhythmDawg
Comey's interpretation, understanding, assumption, belief, inference, or whatever is not proof that he is correct. His understanding is not proof of Trump's intent.
And I am not trying to defend Trump here, because what you posted somewhere else in this thread...something like "at a minimum it is inappropriate and unethical" - I'm paraphrasing - I fully agree with you. But nothing Comey wrote is proof that Trump obstructed justice. People can...and are...make it seem like that, but there is no definitive proof. Even if Comey testifies that he fully believes that Trump was attempting to obstruct, that is making assumptions about his intent. What he said, for what it is, is NOT obstruction.
Comey could have questioned Trump..."Are you asking me to drop the investigation?" "Are you telling me that I need to drop the investigation?" "Are you directing me to drop the investigation?" Comey didn't ask anything like that. He should have to get clarification from the POTUS if he felt uncomfortable. This, in my opinion, is a display of huge lack of judgement on behalf of Comey...and I think more so that Trump's. trump is a business guy, not a politician and not the FBI director. I expect him to make mistakes. Trump, as a business guy, has a team of lawyers to advise him on the law. I can understand why Trump did what he did...although I wouldn't have done it. But I get it. He wanted Comey to be like his other advisers. I think that is Trump's mistake, as that desire was misplaced. Comey knows better than to just leave it how he left it...or he should, anyway. In fact, he should have advised Trump at that point on what obstruction of justice is and how what he was doing could be construed as just that. When he arrived at the white house and realized that it was just the two of them, Comey should have advised Trump right then and there, and left, and told him exactly why. Trump is the kind of person who I believe would respond very well to that. Comey did nothing to inform him of the law, and in my opinion, he should have.
I believe Comey is mostly at fault in all of this. I believe Trump is at fault through ignorance...which is not an excuse. But that also has a major bearing on his lack of intent...quite similar to HRC's issue.