From a news source:
The US-Ukraine minerals deal is markedly different from the original minerals deal proposed by the Trump administration. The initial deal called for Ukraine to use its mineral resources to repay the United States $500 billion for military aid previously provided1. The current deal is expected to give Washington access to Ukraine's critical minerals and other natural resources, with the hope of securing long-term support for Ukraine's defense against Russia4.
Says "markedly different," but I guess you know better.
US News & World Report reports that this deal is a lot different than the original, that Z was prepared to sign after the Oval Office mess, in that this version has ZERO guarantees of profits for the US. There is no set amount ($billions) that the US must realize before Ukraine starts getting a piece of the pie. There are also no security guarantees for Ukraine in this deal, but those were absent in the first deal too. So, no change there.
Bottom line, according to EVERY source, this is a lesser deal for the US than the one Z was prepared to sign in February, but Trump had his temper tantrum.
For me, and other Ukrainian supporters and wanting something good for the US this is not a bad deal, because it should open doors for the US and US companies to develop Ukraine's resources, especially the REMs. Most importantly, it's a shot across Putin's bow.